Tuesday, November 13, 2012

LA Session 11/13/12

I brought salmonella to my session tonight. See?


Unfortunately, only one student attended tonight's session.  They just took an exam on Friday, so it wasn't very surprising.  We held the session in the classroom of First Year, North at 6:00 PM.  Dr. Gillespie covered the first half of chapter 18, so we spent the session talking about viruses.  (Yeah, I know salmonella is a bacterium, but that's what they'll be talking about in lecture tomorrow.)

There were several things that went well in the session tonight.  First, we made a chart that showed characteristics shared by all viruses as well as things that make viruses different from each other.  One thing we talked about was the real-world applications for knowing about viruses (and viroids and prions); we discussed why they mutate so quickly and why we need new vaccines so often.  I was also planning a debate, but since only one student came, we just discussed it as a group.  The student listed first, reasons why a virus should be considered a living organism, then why it should not be considered a living organism.  During this, we talked about how even people who are scientists as a profession and know practically everything about a topic can still disagree on things; science is not "set in stone".

One area of improvement that arose tonight was that the activity planned was for a group of students, so it was only moderately effective with one student participating.  A way to improve this would be to plan an activity suitable for a large group of students as well as an activity for a small group (or just one) students.

When we did the would-be debate, where we discussed both sides of an argument, we talked about how science is not "set in stone".  Even professionals disagree on some hypotheses.  This relates to "Teaching evolution (and all of biology) more effectively"; under "fundamental 2: focus on scientific and critical thinking", Nelson talks about how it is important for students to realize there are (or were at one point) reasonable alternative hypotheses.  He makes an important note that students need to 1) realize there can be alternative hypotheses and 2) appropriate criteria and evidence to declare one hypothesis stronger/weaker.  This way, students don't come to a conclusion that "any choices among answers are arbitrary and based on how one feels about the answers or about the authorities."

No comments:

Post a Comment