Tuesday, October 23, 2012

LA Session 10/23/12

The session today was at 6:00 PM in the classroom of First Year, South.  Only three students were in attendance today.  We talked about chapter 12 and 13 from their textbook, which covers transcription, translation, and gene expression.  A lot of discussion pertained to the differences between transcription and translation, as well as the differences between the processes in prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

I think after the session tonight, the students were able to better visualize what's happening in transcription and translation, as well as think through gene regulation processes.  I showed an animation (http://www.teachersdomain.org/resource/lsps07.sci.life.stru.celltrans/) that I think was helpful with visualizing the processes, so this was a particular success from this session.  With a smaller group, I think it was easier to have a better discussion with everyone participating.  I prepared some discussion questions to talk about ("Why do you think the processes are so similar between prokaryotes and eukaryotes? Why do you think caused there to be a few differences?" "Why do you think most of the regulation happens in transcription?"), so we spent time talking about why things worked the way they did.  When discussing gene regulation, we talked about activators and repressors, and why it made sense to have the sequences in the order that they were in.

One challenge we encountered during this session was that it didn't seem like there was enough time to talk about everything.  By the time we finished with transcription and translation, we didn't have very much time to talk about gene regulation.  (This seemed to be OK with the students, because they wanted to go over transcription and translation a little more.)  This could be fixed for next time by better anticipating how long it would take to go over the processes (and account for the animation time) and planning out topics in "time slots".

One of the successes in this session relates to the article "Questioning and Discussion".  They say in the article (and I think we also talked about it in class) that good discussions don't usually just happen. They take proper preparation.  I think by preparing questions that require students to think critically about what they're learning and why the processes work.  By comparing transcription and translation between prokaryotes and eukaryotes and talking about why they might be similar, students can better understand the importance of major topics like these.  Also, by thinking through what was going on ("why does this repressor need to be there?"), they understand the concepts, like gene regulation, better.

Thursday, October 18, 2012

LA Session 10/16/12

This week's session was in our usual location of FYRH, south's classroom, at our usual time of 6:00PM.  Five students were in attendance.  We went over chapter 11 and the beginning of chapter 12 in their textbook, which covered DNA structure, replication, and the basics of transcription.  Half the time was spent discussing how DNA is important, so storing it must be done effectively.  We talked about the hierarchy of DNA structure (nucleic acids make up a strand, two strands make a double helix, etc.)  We also talked the replication of DNA in a lot of detail, comparing and contrasting the methods used by prokaryotes and eukaryotes. We also prepared some Connect questions for discussion.

One particular success that stands out was that students began to see connections between other topics in the class.  We went back and talked a little about chemistry and hydrogen bonds, since those are extremely important in DNA.  We asked the students to recall the relative strengths of bonds (hydrogen bonds vs. covalent).  A discussion developed about a future topic, evolution; we talked about what DNA did and why it was important to have proofreading mechanisms.

A challenge that was encountered this week was getting through the names of all the enzymes involved: DNA  polymerases I, II, III, IV, DNA helicase, topoisomerase, etc., etc.  A lot of students kept getting confused about which ones did what, especially with the DNA polymerases.  A way to get them to understand it would be to come up with a mnemonic device that includes the number of the polymerase.

Several of the articles have talked about getting students to think scientifically.  When we discussed why DNA was important and the consequences if mistakes were made, the students were thinking scientifically and connecting different topics within the course.

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

LA Session 10/9/12

Tonight's session was held in First Year, South at 6:00PM; 16 students came.  This really surprised me, since they have an exam tomorrow, AND we got pizza for them!  Their exam tomorrow covers chapters 6-10 in their textbook, which includes enzymes, enzyme kinetics, cellular respiration, photosynthesis, cell communication, and multicellularity.  We covered bits of each topic with a JEOPARDY game, which was a lot of fun.  For the most part (since the students have an exam tomorrow), we clarified some things that they were having trouble with (i.e., the difference between NADH and NAD+ +2H+; the difference between gap junctions and plasmodesmata).

I think the Jeopardy game went really well (compared to last week's game, anyway). We had a plan made beforehand, and all the questions were well thought out.  We allowed the students to be in groups of 4, and whoever wrote down the correct answer and held it up first got the points.  This allowed us to cover pieces of each topic, and gave the students time to think of some questions they might have (because you know, when you go in and ask "does anyone have questions?" you just get some crickets.)  The game was pretty short; only lasted about 30-40 minutes.

One challenge we had was a big group of students that sat in the back row and talked when other students were trying to ask questions; they were really distracting, but I wasn't sure what to do about them at the time. One solution might be to break the group up into two smaller groups (although I didn't think the group of 16 was big to begin with); that way, the students don't get bored, and 2 discussions can be going on at one time. If that doesn't work, maybe ask the students direct questions (to make them talk about biology) that way they are participating positively.

This week's successful game relates to interactive engagement, as described in "Teaching evolution (and all of biology) more effectively: strategies for engagement, critical reasoning, and confronting misconceptions".  The students feel like they want to win the game, so they talk with their teammate and make their argument about what answer they think is correct in order to get the reward of points.  I think the games are really exciting; they always make me want to participate more.  This allowed the students to work together and have discussions, but it also provided us with feedback on what material the students knew well and what they needed more help on.  The questions that they wrote down and answered right away (fast enough that we couldn't really tell who held up their paper first) were not things we needed to go over; questions that made the whole group sit and think for a little while (and maybe flip through their textbook) were topics that we knew needed to be brushed over.

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

LA Session 10/2/12

At my session last night, we started out with eight students, then one more came in a little bit later.  It was in the classroom of FYRH South and lasted from 6:00-7:30PM.  Since no new material was covered on Monday of this week (Dr. Gillespie did a review of metabolism), we went over photosynthesis; a majority of the students agreed that's what they needed the most help on.  We ended up playing the game we had planned for last week (but didn't because we didn't have many people).  The students were divided into two teams of four (and let the student who came in late pick which team to be on).  Each team picked their first representative, and they stood on either side of a chair at the front of the room, and a marker placed on the chair.  When the question was brought up on the projector, the first person to grab the marker got to discuss the question with their team, but the representative had to say the team's "official answer".  The questions were all on photosynthesis.

I think the game itself was a HUGE success! It engaged the students, and everyone was very excited.  The competitive aspect in group activities, I think, boosts students' willingness to participate immensely.  After the questions were answered and agreed upon, we discussed why they were right.  I think this was a good way for the students to interact because, even when discussing what the answers might be, they talked through each problem.

A couple issues we had were dealing with timing the responses for the questions and scoring.  We realized after we started that we didn't have a plan made for how much time we would give the students to answer the questions.  After we started, we decided to just give them an arbitrarily appropriate amount of time; as long as they were discussing, we let them continue to discuss. Once the discussion developed into "Which one do you think?" "I don't know, which one do you think?" "I don't know, you pick one", I gave them 15-30 seconds to pick which answer they thought was best.  Some of the questions also had multiple parts (so they should have been worth more points), but since we didn't think about that beforehand, we made each question one point.  Next time we do a game (which will probably be next week), it would be a good idea to do a "test run" and see how long it might take for a student to answer a question.  It would also be good to make different points for the harder questions (maybe like Jeopardy?) or more extensive questions.

The success from this week relates to the article from this week on group work and the face-to-face interactions.  By requiring the representative to voice the team's answer, they each had the opportunity to talk.  They all had to be involved, and they exchanged their ideas when discussing the answers. For example, a part of one question was "Carotenoids absorb ______ and blue light." One girl on the team answering said something along the lines of "Well carotenoids appear red, orange and yellow, so any answer that's not one of those colors", which happened to be green.

Monday, October 1, 2012

Side note

This past weekend, I went with my roommate to the county fair that took place where she was from.  While we were there, we stayed with her aunt, who works as a teacher at the local high school.  Her aunt was talking with some of the other house guests about the school system, and she started talking about formative assessment.  I spoke up, saying, "I learned about that in my education class!"  For some reason I was under the impression that this was all new material (since it's new to me), and I didn't think people who have been teaching for 30 years would know what it was.  It makes me feel really good that there are teachers like her who put in an effort to learn new teaching strategies, even getting close to retirement.